2.5 Meh Stars.
I guess a big part of my problem with this short story was that I simply didn't buy into the main characters reasoning. He allows some guy, he doesn't know who this is, to grope him randomly over and over again.
That started my frowning. It goes on from there - Casper's a virgin, but he's okay with being blindfolded and having his hands bound while mystery-man makes out with him...
This was well written, and I think if I hadn't had such a problem with the main premise of not knowing who the guy was I probably would have liked it more. *shrugs*